優 Excellent 良 Good 常 Average 可  Pass 劣 Poor
傳 送 您 的 評 分 Submit Your Rating 現 時 評 分 結 果 Current Rating Result 瀏 覽 及 撰 寫 意 見 Browse and Write Comments
所 有 用 家 評 分 / 意 見 All Users' Ratings / Comments

評論:
Review:


劇本 Script:
演員 Cast:
製作 Production:
藝術性 Artistic Value:
娛樂性 Entertaiment Value:
  

The story is told with the use of the voice over of the main character, Chiyo. It is compatible to the title of memoirs and an economical way of narration. The film explores the theme of material well beings and fame at the expense of freedom to pursue genuine love.

Director Rob Marshall adopts an unrestricted narrative for almost the entire film except the last sequence in which the restrictedness is completely revealed. Marshall carries forward his cinematographic and editing style from "Chicago" (2002) by using match of actions in unrelated spatial dimension and graphic match. Use of shooting angles to delay revelation of the characters is also common in the film. POV and tail-on follow shots are frequently used to reinforce the sense that Chiyo (young: Suzuka Ohgo / grown: Zhang Ziyi) and other Geishas are fumbling their way. The cello music from Yo-yo Ma is very fine. Yet the use of English instead of Japanese undermines the reality of the content (after all, it's an American production!).

Though the story itself is not overwhelmingly attractive in terms of romance and geisha's hardships, the combination of mise-en-scenes, staging, colours and music in their synergy from Marshall more than compensates the novel's weakness from Arthur Golden.

  

Links to third party sites: The links in this site will let you leave Hong Kong Films' Web. The linked sites are not under our control and we are not responsible for the contents of any linked site, or any link contained in a linked site, or any changes or updates to such sites. The inclusion of any link does not imply endorsement by us, nor does it imply our site is endorsed by the linked site.

Copyright(C) 1999-2006 Hong Kong Internet Ventures. All rights reserved. Privacy Statement